So is tracing really cheating in art?
Tracing in art is universally considered a tool, not cheating. Just like using a ruler or a grid, tracing helps speed up the layout process and ensures accurate proportions. However, simply tracing lines doesn't teach you how to shade, color, or paint.
The artistic community's view on tracing generally boils down to utility, technique, and ethics:
1. The Right Tool for the Job
Many professional artists, muralists, and illustrators use lightboxes, projectors, or transfer paper to save time.
Historical Precedent: Masters like Leonardo da Vinci and Johannes Vermeer are widely believed to have used optical aids like the camera obscura to block out their compositions.
The "Traced" look: Tracing only establishes the outline. Successfully rendering lighting, texture, and shadows relies entirely on your fundamental painting or drawing skills.
2. When it Becomes Problematic
While tracing is perfectly acceptable, it can hinder an artist's growth if overused.
Hindering Skill Development: If you only trace, you may never build your observational skills, eye-hand coordination, or the ability to draw from memory and imagination.
The "Crutch" Effect: Many instructors recommend that beginners learn to draw freehand first, using tracing only later in their development as a shortcut for complex, large-scale work.
3. The Ethical Boundaries (Plagiarism)
Tracing becomes "cheating" and crosses into copyright infringement when it involves plagiarism.
Using Others' Work: Tracing another artist's drawing or a professional photographer's copyrighted image to create a new piece for profit or publication without permission is unethical and illegal.
Best Practices: It is widely agreed across communities like Reddit's r/ArtistLounge that if you trace, you should use your own reference photos and be transparent about your process.
Ultimately, tracing is a mechanical shortcut. It is not a substitute for the creative decisions, stylistic choices, and technical rendering that make a piece of art unique.
Other than this, it’s just personal preference!
The fact is that most artists trace or use a lightbox or a projector all or some of the time. I know several well known artists who use tracing and projectors including an artist who has sold their work at Sotherby’s. There are many many professional artists all over the world who use these tools to get their work done more accurately and faster.
Tracing can actually help you improve your drawing skills because they improve your observation skills, after all if you can see better you’re going to be able to draw better.
If your goal is to improve your drawing skills then you can still trace but use it as an aid to improving your drawing skills by tracing part of your drawing – key elements or part of key elements and then finish with some freehand drawing.
Why do I trace?
When I started drawing again after many years of not, I honed my skills and I became very good at drawing and I could draw human portraits freehand. However as time passed my work became more in demand. The commissions started flowing in. So knowing that I could trace and get my drawing done a lot faster meant I could concentrate on my passion for drawing. And I’m glad I did this because it led to a whole new career in art that I had previously thought impossible!
I wholeheartedly recommend having a go at tracing if you are struggling with accuracy and it is spoiling your enjoyment of drawing.
Whilst we’re on the subject of tracing we can also talk about a grid and using a grid to get a better line drawing. This is a really useful tool. You can also use the grid method to improve your drawing skills by starting off with a small grid and then gradually making your grid bigger so that your relying less on the grid and more on your skills.
Even tracing takes practice. Tracing accurately is a skill in itself and isn’t always a matter of simply tracing the lines that you see, especially with a portrait because photos can hide so much, especially poor quality photos. If you’re a beginner, using poor quality photos will not help you improve so do yourself a favour and use quality photos so you can see more clearly. You have to work out what the lines mean to the structure of the face and this takes practice – it’s virtually impossible to do this if your photo reference is poor, you can’t see what isn’t there!
So is it really cheating?
To answer the original question, excluding the one reason above, NO it’s not cheating. Because a finished piece is so much more that the line drawing that you start with. But ultimately, it is your opinion that matters to you most, do you think it’s cheating or is it just another aid to getting the job done?
It's very much a personal preference!
Famous Tracers (You're in Good Company)
Tracing in art is a long-standing tool used by many legendary creators to transfer compositions, master perspectives, and achieve photorealistic proportions. It is widely used for transferring scale and ensuring accuracy. Notable artists who utilised tracing and optical projection techniques include:
Johannes Vermeer: Widely suspected of using a camera obscura (a darkened room or box with a lens) to project and trace accurate perspectives, lighting, and scale in his masterpieces.
Andy Warhol: Openly embraced the mass-production aesthetic by frequently using projectors to trace iconic photographs for his screenprints.
Leonardo da Vinci: Employed the grid method, perspectographs, and traditional pouncing (rubbing chalk or charcoal on the back of a traced drawing) to transfer complex sketches onto canvas.
Chuck Close: Known for his massive, hyperrealistic photoportraits, he notoriously projected photographs onto giant canvases, traced the outlines, and filled them in with intricate color grids.
Norman Rockwell: Frequently projected and traced his own reference photographs to lay down the flawless, detailed foundations of his illustrations before painting.
Caravaggio: Evidence suggests the Renaissance master used mirrors, lenses, and projected light in his dark studio to trace models directly, allowing for highly dramatic lighting and perspective.
Add comment
Comments