The Best Professional Coloured Pencils for Artists: Prismacolor vs Polychromos vs Luminance
For professional artists, choosing the right coloured pencil brand is not simply a matter of preference — it fundamentally changes how you layer, blend, sharpen, and ultimately create your artwork.
Among serious coloured pencil artists, three brands dominate the conversation:
- Prismacolor Premier
- Faber-Castell Polychromos
- Caran d'Ache Luminance
Each has developed an almost cult-like following, and for good reason. They all produce exceptional results — but they behave very differently on paper.
This guide compares them across the factors that matter most to artists: blending, lightfastness, durability, layering, point retention, price, and overall ease of use.
Wax-Based vs Oil-Based Coloured Pencils
Before comparing brands individually, it’s important to understand the two main binder systems used in professional coloured pencils. This of course is based on my own findings as a professional artist. Other views may well differ from my own.
Wax-Based Pencils
Wax-based pencils are generally softer, creamier, and easier to blend. Colours melt together beautifully and allow for rich painterly transitions.
The downside is something called wax bloom — a cloudy or hazy buildup that can appear on heavily layered areas over time. While it can be wiped away or sealed with fixative, some artists find it frustrating.
Wax-based pencils are usually preferred for:
- Portraiture
- Soft gradients
- Atmospheric realism
- Fast colour coverage
Oil-Based Pencils
Oil-based pencils contain less wax and produce a firmer core.They:
- Hold a sharper point
- Excel at detail work
- Layer cleanly without wax bloom
- Feel more controlled and precise
Oil-based pencils are especially popular for:
- Fine detail rendering
- Wildlife art
- Botanical illustration
- Architectural drawing
- Hyperrealism
If you draw fine hairs, botanical thorns, fur texture, or intricate detail, softer pencils can become frustrating quickly. Oil-based pencils like Polychromos are often the preferred solution.
Prismacolor Premier
Prismacolor Premier pencils are famous for one thing above all else: softness.
Their buttery wax-based cores glide across paper effortlessly and blend with almost no resistance. For artists transitioning from beginner pencils into professional-grade materials, Prismacolor often feels instantly enjoyable and forgiving.
Strengths
Exceptional Blending
Prismacolor pencils blend seamlessly. Colours can be burnished together to create painterly surfaces with minimal visible pencil grain.
Rich Pigment
The colour payoff is immediate and intense, making them excellent for vibrant portraiture and expressive work.
Fast Coverage
Large areas can be filled quickly because the soft cores deposit substantial pigment.
Excellent for Portraits
Skin tones and soft transitions are where Prismacolor truly shines.
Weaknesses
Fragile Cores
This is the brand’s biggest criticism. The cores can crack internally, even before sharpening, which leads to frustrating breakage.
Poor Point Retention
Sharp tips dull quickly. Artists focused on ultra-fine details may constantly need to resharpen.
Wax Bloom
Heavy layering often produces visible wax bloom over time.
Lower Lightfastness Consistency
Some Prismacolor colours are reasonably lightfast, but overall archival performance is less consistent than premium competitors.
Best For:
- Portrait artists
- Beginners entering professional work
- Artists who prefer painterly blending
- Soft realism and expressive styles
Caran d'Ache Luminance
Caran d’Ache Luminance pencils occupy the ultra-premium end of the coloured pencil market.
They were engineered specifically with museum-quality lightfastness in mind, making them especially attractive to artists selling originals or producing gallery work.
Strengths
Industry-Leading Lightfastness
Luminance pencils are specifically designed for archival longevity. Many colours achieve the highest international lightfastness ratings available. For professional artists selling work, this matters enormously.
Soft Yet Controlled
Luminance manages an impressive balance:
- softer than Polychromos
- firmer and more stable than Prismacolor. This gives them luxurious blending qualities without becoming overly fragile.
- Exceptional Pigment Density. Colours appear deep, rich, and sophisticated, especially in muted earth tones and portrait palettes.
Superior Build Quality
The pencils feel premium in every respect, from wood casing to core consistency.
Weaknesses
- Extremely Expensive. Luminance is among the most expensive coloured pencil lines in the world.
- Smaller Colour Range. Compared to Prismacolor and Polychromos, the available colour selection is more limited.
- Softer Than Polychromos. Although more durable than Prismacolor, they still won’t maintain needle-sharp points as long as Polychromos.
Best For
- Professional selling artists
- Gallery work
- Commission portraiture
- Archival artwork
- Artists prioritising lightfastness
Faber-Castell Polychromos
Polychromos pencils are considered by many professionals to be the gold standard for precision and control.
Unlike Prismacolor, Polychromos pencils use a firmer oil-based core that holds an extremely sharp point.
Strengths
- Outstanding Point Retention
- This is where Polychromos dominates.
- The pencils stay sharp significantly longer than softer wax-based alternatives.
For artists drawing:
- fur
- feathers
- eyelashes
- botanical textures
- architectural detail
Polychromos can feel transformative.
Layering Performance
Because they contain less wax, they can be layered repeatedly without developing bloom or becoming muddy.
Durability
The harder cores resist breakage extremely well.
Controlled Colour Application
Polychromos allows precise pressure control and subtle glazing techniques that many hyperrealist artists love.
Weaknesses
Less Creamy
Artists used to soft pencils may initially find Polychromos less satisfying or slower to blend.
Slower Coverage
Large areas take longer to fill because the pencils deposit colour more gradually.
Requires More Patience
These pencils reward technical layering rather than aggressive burnishing.
Best For
- Wildlife artists
- Botanical illustrators
- Hyperrealists
- Artists focused on detail and control
- Professional archival work
Lightfastness: Why It Matters
If your work is intended for sale, exhibition, or long-term display, lightfastness should be a major consideration.
Poorly lightfast pencils can fade dramatically after prolonged UV exposure.
Best Lightfastness Performance
Excellent - Caran d’Ache Luminance and Derwent Lightfast
Very Good - Faber-Castell Polychromos
Mixed - Prismacolor Premier
Artists producing commission work or gallery pieces should strongly consider pencils specifically designed for archival permanence.
Comparisons
Prismacolor offers outstanding value for artists wanting professional softness without premium pricing.
Polychromos sits comfortably in the middle — expensive, but highly durable and long-lasting.
Luminance is unquestionably a luxury product, but for serious professionals the archival reliability may justify the investment.
Which Coloured Pencil Brand Is Best?
The truth is that there is no universally “best” coloured pencil — only the best pencil for your style of work.
Choose Prismacolor Premier if:
- You love soft painterly blending
- You primarily create portraits
- You want vibrant colour quickly
- You prefer a forgiving drawing experience
Choose Polychromos if:
- You prioritise detail
- You draw wildlife or botanical subjects
- You want maximum control
- You dislike wax bloom
Choose Luminance if:
- You sell professional artwork
- Lightfastness is essential
- You want premium performance
- You prefer archival-grade materials
Final Thoughts
Many professional coloured pencil artists eventually combine brands rather than staying loyal to just one.
A common workflow is:
- Polychromos for structure and detail
- Prismacolor or Luminance for rich blending and finishing layers
Ultimately, the “best” coloured pencil is the one that supports your technique, subject matter, and artistic goals.
Understanding the strengths and weaknesses of each system will help you build a toolkit that genuinely improves your artwork — rather than fighting against it.
My personal favourite, all things considered, are Prismacolor Premier pencils. Probably for no other reason than Prismacolor was the brand I started out with when I turned professional and I find those easier to use than other brands. At the end of the day it's a personal choice.
I hope this has been of some help to anyone looking to upgrade their coloured pencils. Good luck and enjoy your pencils...
Oh by the way I buy all my new pencils from The Coloured Pencil Shop They are very reasonably priced, stock all brands and there is no minimum order requirement so you can just buy one pencil if you want to!
Add comment
Comments